Posts

Showing posts with the label business model

The Intrinsic Weaknesses of the Big LEO Constellation Business Model: Excess Capacity, High Depreciation, and Price Wars

Image
The author argues that large LEO constellations are inherently inefficient because most of each orbit the low lying LEO satellites provide little or no service: "Our analysis suggests Starlink’s global coverage model leads to a fill rate of around 8% to 10%. This is unsurprising given that about 71% of Earth’s surface is covered by water, and only 1% consists of densely populated urban areas where broadband demand is highest. More than 90% of these satellites spend most of their operational lives over oceans and remote, unpopulated areas, representing inherent inefficiency."  So his point is the brute force LEO approach is inherently capital intensive and that the revenue per dollar invested is actually quite low. Moreover, depreciation is quite high as LEO satellites have only five year lifespans due to atmospheric drag and limited fuel. This causes no problem in a case where the provider has a quasi-monopoly on service like Starlink and uses its space freight division to su...

AI Data Centers: A Fragile Business Model Requiring Perfect Execution & A Lot Of Luck

Image
1. Massive capital expenditures. Much higher capital intensity per rack than a standard data center.  2. Extremely high operating costs due to the power intensity of AI infrastructure. 3. Low customer switching costs shift negotiating power from supplier to customer.  4. Huge gap between capex and revenue flows: 2 to 5 years. 5. Heavy dependence on debt financing and hence vulnerability to rising risk premiums and interest rates. 6. Underlying technology, large language models, is fundamentally flawed according to many computer scientists. This is corroborated by persistent hallucinations and weak problem solving abilities. 7. Large language models show sharply diminishing returns to scale. 8. Luck is required because there are only a few, very large customers for these projects and loss of a single customer can kill a project. Luck is also important because any of these data center projects requires upgrades to the power transmission grid and also generator capacity. 

FCC Approves Deployment of Logos Space's 4,178 LEO Satellite Deployment

Image
Logos Space is a new LEO satellite provider that plans to put over four thousand LEO birds into seven orbital shells in the 870 to 920 kilometer span above the Earth. Logos is taking an unusual approach. Its target market includes businesses and governments, but excludes households. Instead of Internet, Logos offers highly secure Layer 2 MPLS Ethernet services. These are the core products, not transit. To improve security over traditional satellite services, it is operating in the high frequency V and E spectrum bands along with the lower frequency K band. This enables the use of narrow beams to connect the customer premise equipment to a satellite. These narrow beams are much more difficult to intercept for eavesdropping or jamming.  Most LEO constellations provide exclusively Layer 3 services. Satellite frequency spectrum is a finite, strictly limited resource. So overbooked or oversubscribed transit has been the only service that traditionally made economic sense. N...

The Starlink Financial Mystery: Caveats Concerning Its Profitability

Image
Let's be clear. LEO satellite service is an unproven business model. Obviously, if prices are high enough or the service is a monopoly, it will work. But no complete financial picture is public at this point. This is why the planned 2026 IPO is so interesting. The prospectus will reveal enough to make an informed judgment. But despite stubborn optimism to the contrary, there is no strong evidence that LEO Internet is highly profitable. I doubt even Starlink investors have the company's complete financial details except for a few high profile venture capitalists. Starlink does release an annual report. It is best characterized as a slick marketing pitch designed to give the impression that Starlink is an unstoppable juggernaut that reflects historical inevitability. All Bow to Caesar. What are the missing details? 1. Depreciation. 2. Customer acquisition costs. 3. Operating expenses. 4. Capital replacement costs. Depreciation is important because LEOs are like...

Peeling Back The Onion: Possible 2026 SpaceX IPO - Part 1

Image
The LEO satellite business model is one of the most interesting topics in telecommunications today. LEO satellites are not a 'new technology'. It is really just a new approach to providing Internet access without any intellectual or patent moat to prevent the entry of new competitors. There could be a know how moat, but the number of LEO satellite networks entering the market over the next 5 year suggests it is very shallow. LEO satellites provide Last Mile access using low Earth orbits ranging from 300 kilometers (180 US miles) to 2,000 kilometers (1200 miles). Each bird as they are affectionately called in the industry takes only 90 to 120 minutes to complete an orbit. Their orbits can take a variety of shapes. For example, a LEO orbit could be elliptical in order to achieve a closer approach to the Earth at some points along the path for more detailed image or data collection. Or the LEO could fly longitudinally from North Pole to South Pole and back again. Hence LEO satelli...

Ten Modest Proposals For Making Subsea & Wholesale Carriers Profitable Again - Part I

Image
Pay salesmen low salaries and 5% to 10% of on-net revenue. A good salesman does not need a high salary. He or she achieves high income by selling. It is what they enjoy doing. This is the standard Wall Street broker compensation package. New brokers end up sharing apartments with lots of other brokers and commuting from New Jersey. Real sales meritocracy is pay for performance.  Profits are not maximized by paying a high salary combined with low commission rates, and high quotas. It simply creates huge staff turnover as people charm themselves into a high paying job, produce only one or two deals over their first six to 12 months, and then jump ship just before they are going to fired. I have seen it happen time and time again. The empty suit charmers. The resume red flag is a sales guy or gal moving from carrier to carrier every 1 to 2 years. The resulting churn from these bad apples dramatically lowers sales revenue per employee. Plus it rewards a few select salesmen who were luc...