The Intrinsic Weaknesses of the Big LEO Constellation Business Model: Excess Capacity, High Depreciation, and Price Wars
The author argues that large LEO constellations are inherently inefficient because most of each orbit the low lying LEO satellites provide little or no service: "Our analysis suggests Starlink’s global coverage model leads to a fill rate of around 8% to 10%. This is unsurprising given that about 71% of Earth’s surface is covered by water, and only 1% consists of densely populated urban areas where broadband demand is highest. More than 90% of these satellites spend most of their operational lives over oceans and remote, unpopulated areas, representing inherent inefficiency." So his point is the brute force LEO approach is inherently capital intensive and that the revenue per dollar invested is actually quite low. Moreover, depreciation is quite high as LEO satellites have only five year lifespans due to atmospheric drag and limited fuel. This causes no problem in a case where the provider has a quasi-monopoly on service like Starlink and uses its space freight division to su...