Posts

The Intrinsic Weaknesses of the Big LEO Constellation Business Model: Excess Capacity, High Depreciation, and Price Wars

Image
The author argues that large LEO constellations are inherently inefficient because most of each orbit the low lying LEO satellites provide little or no service: "Our analysis suggests Starlink’s global coverage model leads to a fill rate of around 8% to 10%. This is unsurprising given that about 71% of Earth’s surface is covered by water, and only 1% consists of densely populated urban areas where broadband demand is highest. More than 90% of these satellites spend most of their operational lives over oceans and remote, unpopulated areas, representing inherent inefficiency."  So his point is the brute force LEO approach is inherently capital intensive and that the revenue per dollar invested is actually quite low. Moreover, depreciation is quite high as LEO satellites have only five year lifespans due to atmospheric drag and limited fuel. This causes no problem in a case where the provider has a quasi-monopoly on service like Starlink and uses its space freight division to su...

Photos of the Interior of the TAT-14 Netherlands Cable Landing Station: Joint Box Linking CLS to Beach Fibre

Image
This is the joint box where the fibre from the beach manhole is connected to CLS interior fibre cabling. It is an interface or access point.

December In Johannesburg - Roderick The Wandering Telecom Nomad

Image
Hi Gang, I arrive December 4th and will probably depart January 3rd. Will be staying in the safe neighborhood of Sandton, on the North side of the city. I will be working with Transmission Co (https://www.transmissionco.net/). Available to meet and assist you in your projects. Looking forward to indepth discussions and collaboration on projects and deals. 

Netherland's TAT-14 Cable Landing Station Photos - Part 2

Image
As mentioned in my first post, the TAT-14 subsea network suffered notorious outages, particularly on the Bude/Denmark segment where the cable hugged the Danish, Dutch and Belgium coasts and then traversed the English Channel's busy shipping lanes. About 85% of cable damage world wide occurs in waters one thousand meters deep or less. The two main culprits are fishing and ship anchors. Unfortunately, technology at the time permitted only shallow burial on the continental shelf off the Netherlands, Belgium, and through the English Channel. One meter was the max, but average burial much less, probably only 30 to 50 centimeters. This same region is known for sand waves, horizontal currents that can move several meters of sea floor deposit and disinter a buried cable. The design combined with shallow burial was a recipe for disaster.  The consortium was certainly aware that their design was high risk, but every member wanted a landing and the consensus was that a ring mitigated the risk...

Netherlands TAT-14 Cable Landing Station Photos - Part 1

Image
TAT-14 was the last traditional carrier consortium cable across the Atlantic. It was decommissioned in 2020. It was a two cable ring design and suffered notorious double outages. Below is a peak at a network monitoring computer terminal. Notice the vintage Sun computer. 

Equinix 10G Wave Specials - Direct Contract With Network Operator

Image
1. Lisbon/Capetown; $5,500; 1 year term; $5,500 NRC. 2. Lagos OADC/Lisbon; $5,000; 1 year term; $5,500 NRC. 3. Lagos OADC/Capetown CT1; $4,750 MRC; year term; $5,500 NRC. Remark: Equiano soars above the rest of African cables in terms of reliability. Plus the only cross connect charges are at carrier neutral data center POPs. 

The Class of 2027: META's Pacific Orca Cable

Image
This new 6 fiber pair cable directly connects Taiwan and the United States. It is a relatively low capacity system clocking 12.8 Tbps per fibre pair or 76.8 Tbps in total. It is the norm in our era for new ocean spanning cables to have at least 12 pairs and as many as 24. In that sense Orca is a throw back to the age of low fibre pair count coherent optical networks as opposed to the current high count spatial division multiplexing approach pioneered by Google's Dunant cable. Most likely META's traffic forecast is insufficient to justify a bigger count as Taiwan is a niche market of only 23 million people. While its economic significance is hard to exaggerate as the world's leading supplier of semiconductor chips, population still determines the size of traffic flows with a few exceptions like Singapore. It would not be surprising given the cable's transmission capacity if META keeps its all for its own use.  META subsidiaries land and hold the cable landing licenses o...

Google's View On Orbital Data Centers

Image
Pundits have wrecklessly proclaimed that Google believes in orbital data centers. A more accurate description is that the hyperscaler is exploring the idea's potential and obstacles by conducting orbital experiments like the SunCatcher satellite. But Google has no delusions that orbital data centers are a real alternative to terrestrial facilities for the next 10 to 20 years. Google runs lots of experiments because it has lots of cash.  At a recent conference Google's head of data center energy expressed skepticism that orbital data centers make sense any time soon. The costs could be as much as 100x their terrestrial counterpartsin the case where maintaining and upgrading hardware is included. To be clear, 100x was not the best estimate, but reflects the fact that greenfield developments involving new and untested technologies generally result in massive overruns. Moreover, costs depend on whether it is a throw away orbital data center where no components are replaced or repai...

Starlink's Dynamic (Congestion) Pricing Illustrates The Capacity Limits of Satellite Technology

Image
Starlink is introducing congestion pricing in rural America in places like Kansas and Missouri despite a 10,000 satellite constellation. There is only one credible explanation: capacity shortages. Moreover, adding satellites will not fix the problem. Physics and mathematics set non-negotiable limits on per subscriber bandwidth. Enormous Satellite Constellations Yield Only A Trickle of Throughput Per Square Kilometer Starlink's V3 satellite can transmit a terabit per second to Earth. Assume generously that Musk has 42,000 of them four or five years in the future. That's 42 petabits of download capacity. The average person or even the business community will be fooled into thinking this is enormous capacity. Assume it is evenly distributed over the earth's surface of 520 million square kilometers for sake of simplicity. That equals only 82 megabits per square kilometer. Not a flood, just a trickle.  Now you can place more satellites in certain orbits to target more densely po...

Highly Scalable/Granular Layer 1 10G Service Using 100G Ports: Mombasa/JB1

Image
Cable: 2Africa. A point: JB1, South Africa. Z point: IColo 1, IColo 2, Telehouse or Seacom CLS. Initial Bandwidth: 10G. Granular Layer 1 FlexE service can be upgraded in 1G increments up to 100G. FlexE Protocol 1. Granular Layer 1 with Ethernet wrapping. 2. No jitter. 3. Layer 1 latency. 4. No Ethernet switching. 5. FlexE: https://www.oiforum.com/technical-work/hot-topics/flex-ethernet-flexe-2/.

Chart of Google & META Subsea Fiber Optic Cable Projects

Image
Google has been the undisputed leader in hyperscaler projects. I believe this reflects its web search and advertising businesses. These involve relatively high traffic flows due to transactions, transfers of personal and web site data, and updating edge servers. Many of the projects listed below are joint projects with network operators and other hyperscalers. Google's solo projects include Dhivaru, Proa, Topaz, SOL, TPU, Boson, Grace Hopper, Junior, Monet, Dunant, Curie, Firmina, Equiano, Nuvem, Umoja, three Indian cables, Bulikula, Tabua, Honomoana, Halailia, Taihai, SOL, TalayLink, Alisios, Canoa, Olaluz, and others.  Facebook's solo projects include Anjana, Waterworth, Petal, Aurora, and Orca. Facebook is more likely to do joint projects rather than take 100% ownership and control. I think this reflects less international traffic because its social media traffic stays within certain regions like North America, Japan, Europe, Africa, etc.

The Famous Léon Thévenin Cable Ship

Image
The famous Léon Thévenin cable ship holds the Atlantic record for repairs with 30 over a 29 year period. I believe a repair in this context includes fixing multiple cables during a single outing. The record refers to repairs within the Atlantic Ocean Agreement service area. It is not a cable laying vessel. Léon Charles Thévenin was a French telegraph engineer famous for his Thévenin's theorem, an extension of Ohm's law to complex electrical circuits.

AI Slump Gathers Momentum: Microsoft Terminates Oracle Compute Deal

Image
Microsoft has declined to renew a compute agreement with Oracle, partly on the grounds that the Nvidia chips are too old. This supports Michael Burry's contention that GPUs depreciate faster than the five or six years life span that the AI industry uses in accounting treatments. This in turn suggests that AI data center profits are exaggerated. "Microsoft Corp. is winding down an arrangement to rent AI computing from Oracle Corp., part of a larger reassessment of billions of dollars in cloud partnerships. In recent months, Microsoft has been turning off rented computing capacity from Oracle after declining to renew the contract, according to people familiar with the matter. Over time, the computing Microsoft was renting became less useful because it no longer fit the company’s specifications, said the people, who requested anonymity to discuss a private matter. The Oracle hardware used older-generation Nvidia Corp. chips, the people said." Click for more details: https://...

A Photo Of The Submarine Line Termination Equipment In A Cable Landing Station Circa Early 2000s

Image
The SLTE footprint has dramatically shrunk over the last quarter century due to Moore's Law and better optics. As the footprint and power requirements fell, the incentive to migrate the SLTEs to carrier neutral data centers increased because colocation costs fell.

Exaggerated AI Data Center & Hyperscaler Profits: GPU Depreciation

Image
 Microsoft has declined to renew a compute agreement with Oracle, partly on the grounds that the Nvidia chips are too old. This supports Michael Burry's contention that GPUs depreciate faster than the five or six years life span that the AI industry uses in accounting treatments. This in turn suggests that AI data center profits are exaggerated. "Microsoft Corp. is winding down an arrangement to rent AI computing from Oracle Corp., part of a larger reassessment of billions of dollars in cloud partnerships. In recent months, Microsoft has been turning off rented computing capacity from Oracle after declining to renew the contract, according to people familiar with the matter. Over time, the computing Microsoft was renting became less useful because it no longer fit the company’s specifications, said the people, who requested anonymity to discuss a private matter. The Oracle hardware used older-generation Nvidia Corp. chips, the people said." Click here for more details: ht...

The Granular FlexE Standard: An Attractive Option For Smaller ISPs

Image
Recently a client wanted a port and burst Layer 2 service, similar to what Megaport offers in many parts of the world. The customer wanted to pay a fixed port fee and a variable fee for bursting traffic. In the past this setup used Layer 2 Switched Ethernet. The drawback was the cost of Ethernet switching, network management, and the possibility that the provider would severely overbook the service. Making money on such a service is very hard without overbooking. However, most large capacity providers just sell dumb, Layer 1 pipes. So until recently smaller ISPs had few options. Either Megaport or standard chunky Layer 1 waves. The challenge is that many ISPs has peak traffic well below standard 100G wave services, but above 10G. So rightsizing the network is extremely hard. The good news is that the Optical Internetworking Forum developed the FlexE interface standard, which I view as a Layer 1.5 option. It enjoys all the advantages of layer 1 in terms of hard traffic separation, optic...

AI Data Centers: A Fragile Business Model Requiring Perfect Execution & A Lot Of Luck

Image
1. Massive capital expenditures. Much higher capital intensity per rack than a standard data center.  2. Extremely high operating costs due to the power intensity of AI infrastructure. 3. Low customer switching costs shift negotiating power from supplier to customer.  4. Huge gap between capex and revenue flows: 2 to 5 years. 5. Heavy dependence on debt financing and hence vulnerability to rising risk premiums and interest rates. 6. Underlying technology, large language models, is fundamentally flawed according to many computer scientists. This is corroborated by persistent hallucinations and weak problem solving abilities. 7. Large language models show sharply diminishing returns to scale. 8. Luck is required because there are only a few, very large customers for these projects and loss of a single customer can kill a project. Luck is also important because any of these data center projects requires upgrades to the power transmission grid and also generator capacity. 

ADC Cable Capacity For Sale & Quick Delivery: 100G ~ $12.5K MRC

Image
What a deal!!! Get yourself a promotion, buy now. 🙂 A point: SG1. Z point: Maruyama CLS. Service: Layer 100G Wave. Interface: 100GE. Term: 1 Year. Delivery: Under 4 weeks.

Modern AI, Large Language Models, Are Fundamentally Flawed

Image
Some claim that Pangram, an AI program, is good at detecting AI written text. So I tested it on Shakespeare. Apparently the Bard was using AI in the 16th century ... Large language models (LLMs) are not logic engines. They are huge nonlinear statistical models with huge number of parameters, in some cases as many as three trillion. LLMs are black boxes. They spit out answers, but it is not clear how they reach those conclusions. Moreover, complicated statistical models are fragile. This means they provide reasonable answers the majority of the time, but will from time to time produce bizarre responses. In contrast, human intelligence is quite robust. Outliers are extremely rare. 

My 2026 Nigerian Peering Forum Presentation On African Subsea Cables

Image
 https://drive.google.com/file/d/1DgndmDXSnGOa5BiWZsVv0pQ_bEx45bhw/view?usp=sharing